Is Birria Beef or Pork? This is a question that many food lovers and birria enthusiasts ask when exploring this flavorful Mexican dish. The answer depends on tradition, region, and personal preference.
Originally from Jalisco, Mexico, birria was traditionally made with goat meat. However, as the dish spread across different regions, people began using beef and, in some cases, pork. Today, beef is the most common meat for birria, especially in the United States, while some regions in Mexico still use pork as a variation.
But when it comes to authenticity and taste, is birria beef or pork the better option? In this guide, we’ll explore the origins of birria, the differences between beef and pork birria, the best cuts to use, and how to cook and serve it. By the end, you’ll have a clear answer to whether birria should be made with beef or pork and which suits your taste best.
Want to learn how to make the perfect birria tacos? Check out this ultimate birria tacos guide!
1: Traditional Birria Meat Choices
The Origins of Birria in Mexican Cuisine
Birria dates back to the 16th century during the Spanish colonization of Mexico. When the Spanish introduced goats to the region, they quickly became overpopulated. The indigenous people of Jalisco developed a slow-cooking method using dried chilies and spices to make the tough goat meat tender and flavorful.
This slow-braised dish, known as birria, became a staple in Mexican cuisine, served in a rich, spicy broth called consomé.
Why Goat Meat Was the Original Choice
Goat meat was the most accessible protein in Jalisco, making it the natural choice for birria. However, goat meat is lean and slightly gamey, requiring long hours of cooking to develop its signature tenderness and depth of flavor.
The slow-cooking process, combined with a marinade of dried chilies, garlic, vinegar, and Mexican spices, turned the tough meat into a delicious, comforting dish.
How Beef Became Popular in Birria
Over time, birria’s popularity expanded beyond Jalisco. In northern Mexico and the United States, beef became the preferred meat for several reasons:
- Beef was more widely available than goat.
- Beef’s fat content made it juicier and more flavorful.
- The texture of beef worked better for tacos, a modern twist on traditional birria.
Today, most restaurants and street vendors in the U.S. serve birria de res (beef birria), especially in the form of quesabirria tacos, which are dipped in rich consomé for extra flavor.
Pork birria a regional variation but is far less common than beef birria. Some cooks enjoy using pork for its tenderness and mild sweetness, but it has not gained the same widespread popularity as beef.
2: Is Birria Beef or Pork? The Answer
Beef Birria: Why It’s More Common Today
Although birria was originally made with goat, beef has become the most widely used meat for this dish, especially in the United States and northern Mexico. There are several reasons why beef birria, or birria de res, is more popular today.
First, beef is much easier to find than goat meat. In many regions, especially outside of Mexico, goat meat can be difficult to source, whereas beef is available in almost every grocery store and butcher shop. This accessibility has made beef the go-to choice for home cooks and restaurants alike.
Second, beef’s natural fat content makes it ideal for slow-cooked dishes like birria. Cuts like chuck roast, short ribs, and brisket have a perfect balance of meat and fat, which results in a tender, juicy texture after being braised for several hours. This richness makes beef birria especially flavorful when used for birria tacos, where the meat is dipped in the consomé and crisped on a griddle.
Finally, beef birria has gained immense popularity through social media, food trucks, and restaurants, especially in the form of quesabirria tacos. The demand for these cheesy, crispy tacos has further cemented beef as the preferred meat for birria.
Pork Birria: A Regional Variation
While beef birria dominates in most places, some regions in Mexico still prepare birria with pork, also known as birria de cerdo. This version is less common but is still enjoyed in certain areas where pork is more readily available.
Pork birria is typically made using cuts like pork shoulder or pork ribs, which are naturally tender and slightly sweet. Unlike beef, pork requires a little less cooking time, making it a faster alternative for those who don’t want to wait hours for their birria to be ready.
The flavor of pork birria is also slightly different. Pork has a milder taste compared to beef, and when slow-cooked in a chili-based marinade, it absorbs the spices and seasonings beautifully. Some people prefer pork birria for its softer texture and lighter flavor, while others argue that beef has a deeper, richer taste.
Although pork birria is not as widely known as beef birria, it remains an important variation of the dish. Some families and restaurants still prepare birria de cerdo, keeping this regional tradition alive.
Comparing Beef, Pork, and Goat Birria
When deciding between beef, pork, or goat for birria, the choice comes down to personal preference and availability. Each type of meat brings a unique texture and flavor to the dish.
| Meat Type | Texture | Flavor | Best Used For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beef | Rich, tender, fatty | Deep, smoky, savory | Tacos, quesabirria, consomé |
| Pork | Soft, slightly sweet | Mild, juicy | Stews, tamales, enchiladas |
| Goat | Lean, slightly gamey | Strong, traditional | Authentic Mexican birria |
Beef remains the most popular choice today, especially for tacos, due to its bold flavor and tender texture. Pork, on the other hand, provides a slightly sweeter, softer alternative that works well in stews and other Mexican dishes. Goat, while the most traditional, is less common outside of Mexico but is still used by those looking for an authentic experience.
Ultimately, there is no right or wrong answer—birria can be delicious no matter which meat you choose. The key is slow-cooking the meat with the right spices to bring out the dish’s signature richness and depth of flavor. In the next section, we’ll explore the differences in taste and texture between beef and pork birria.
3: Beef Birria vs. Pork Birria: Flavor and Texture Differences
How Beef Birria Tastes Compared to Pork
One of the biggest differences between beef birria and pork birria is the flavor. Beef birria has a deep, bold taste with a smoky, slightly charred richness that comes from its high fat content and slow-cooking process. When beef is simmered for hours in a marinade of dried chilies, garlic, and spices, it develops an intense umami flavor that pairs perfectly with the spicy and tangy notes of the broth.
Pork birria, on the other hand, has a milder, slightly sweeter flavor. Pork naturally has a softer taste compared to beef, and when cooked in a similar marinade, it absorbs the flavors of the spices while maintaining a lighter, juicier texture. Some people enjoy pork birria for its subtle sweetness, which balances well with the heat of the chilies.
For those who love strong, meaty flavors, beef birria is usually the preferred choice. However, for those looking for a tender, juicy option with a bit of natural sweetness, pork birria can be a great alternative.
Which Meat is More Tender and Juicy?
Both beef and pork can be extremely tender when cooked properly, but they have different textures.
Beef cuts like chuck roast, short ribs, and brisket contain a good amount of connective tissue and fat, which break down during the slow-cooking process. This results in a tender, pull-apart texture that holds up well in tacos and other dishes.
Pork, especially cuts like pork shoulder or pork butt, is naturally softer and more tender than beef. It doesn’t require as much cooking time to reach the perfect level of tenderness. However, because pork has less connective tissue than beef, it can become too soft or even mushy if overcooked.
In terms of juiciness, beef tends to retain more moisture due to its fat content, making it a great option for tacos that need a bit of crisping on the griddle. Pork, while juicy, has a finer texture that can sometimes break apart more easily.
Cooking Times and Methods for Each
The cooking method also plays a role in how beef and pork birria turn out.
- Beef birria typically takes 3 to 4 hours to cook, as the tougher cuts require more time to break down. The long braising process allows the fat and collagen to render, creating a rich, flavorful dish.
- Pork birria cooks a little faster, usually within 2.5 to 3 hours, since pork shoulder and other cuts are naturally more tender. While pork doesn’t need as much cooking time, letting it simmer in the broth for longer can help deepen its flavor.
In the end, the choice between beef and pork birria depends on personal preference. Beef offers a bold, meaty flavor with a firmer texture, while pork provides a slightly sweeter, more delicate bite. Both can be incredibly delicious when slow-cooked with the right spices and served with the traditional consomé.
4: Cooking Birria with Different Meats
Traditional Birria de Res (Beef Birria) Recipe
Beef birria is the most popular version today, especially for making birria tacos. The key to achieving its rich flavor is marinating the meat with a blend of dried chilies, garlic, and spices before slow-cooking it until tender.
Ingredients:
- 3 pounds chuck roast, short ribs, or brisket
- 4 dried guajillo chilies
- 2 dried ancho chilies
- 1 chipotle pepper in adobo
- 5 cloves garlic
- 1 onion, chopped
- 2 cups beef broth
- 1 tablespoon apple cider vinegar
- 1 teaspoon cumin
- 1 teaspoon oregano
- 1 teaspoon smoked paprika
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 1 teaspoon black pepper
Cooking Method:
- Remove stems and seeds from the dried chilies. Toast them in a dry pan for a few seconds to release their oils.
- Blend the toasted chilies with garlic, onion, vinegar, and spices, adding a bit of broth if needed to form a thick marinade.
- Coat the beef with the marinade and let it sit for at least three hours or overnight for deeper flavor.
- In a large pot, add the marinated beef and cover it with beef broth. Simmer on low heat for about three to four hours until the meat is tender and easily shredded.
- Serve the beef with its broth or use it for tacos, dipping the tortillas into the consomé before frying them on a hot griddle.
Pork Birria Recipe: A Different Take
Pork birria is a lesser-known but delicious alternative to beef birria. The sweetness of pork pairs well with the spicy and tangy flavors of the chili marinade.
Ingredients:
- 3 pounds pork shoulder or pork butt
- 3 dried guajillo chilies
- 1 dried pasilla chili
- 3 cloves garlic
- 1 onion, chopped
- 2 cups chicken or pork broth
- 1 tablespoon apple cider vinegar
- 1 teaspoon cinnamon
- 1 teaspoon cumin
- 1 teaspoon oregano
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 1 teaspoon black pepper
Cooking Method:
- Toast and soak the dried chilies, then blend them with garlic, onion, vinegar, and spices to create a smooth marinade.
- Coat the pork with the marinade and let it rest for at least two hours, preferably overnight.
- Place the pork in a pot and add broth. Simmer on low heat for about two and a half to three hours until fork-tender.
- Shred the pork and serve with the broth or use it in tacos, tamales, or stews.
Slow Cooker vs. Instant Pot vs. Stovetop Methods
Birria can be prepared using different cooking methods depending on the time and equipment available.
- Slow Cooker: This is the easiest method. After marinating, place the meat and broth in a slow cooker and cook on low for 6 to 8 hours or on high for 4 to 5 hours.
- Instant Pot: For a faster option, use a pressure cooker. Cook the marinated meat with broth on high pressure for about 45 minutes, then allow a natural release for 15 minutes.
- Stovetop: The traditional method involves simmering the meat in a pot for several hours until tender, occasionally skimming the broth for a cleaner flavor.
Each method results in tender, flavorful birria, but the stovetop and slow cooker methods allow the flavors to develop more deeply over time.
5: Best Meat Cuts for Birria
Best Cuts for Beef Birria
Choosing the right cut of beef is essential for making tender and flavorful birria. The best cuts have a good balance of meat, fat, and connective tissue, which breaks down during slow cooking to create a rich and juicy texture.
- Chuck roast – One of the most popular choices for beef birria. It has excellent marbling, making it tender and flavorful after slow cooking.
- Short ribs – add extra depth to the broth due to their bone-in richness. They create an intensely beefy flavor and a soft, melt-in-your-mouth texture.
- Brisket – Known for its high fat content, brisket becomes incredibly soft when slow-cooked, making it a great option for birria.
- Beef shank – This cut includes the bone marrow, which enhances the consomé, giving it a deeper, more complex taste.
- Oxtail – Though less common, oxtail adds a gelatinous quality to the broth, resulting in a thicker and richer consomé.
When making beef birria, many cooks combine different cuts to achieve the perfect balance of tenderness and flavor. For example, a mix of chuck roast and short ribs can create a richer dish than using just one cut alone.
Best Cuts for Pork Birria
For those who prefer pork birria, selecting the right cut is just as important. Pork is naturally more tender than beef, but using the correct cut will ensure the meat remains juicy and full of flavor.
- Pork shoulder (pork butt) – The best cut for pork birria, as it has the perfect amount of fat to keep the meat moist during slow cooking.
- Pork ribs – Adding ribs to the broth enhances the dish with extra richness, making the consomé even more flavorful.
- Pork leg – A leaner cut that still works well for birria, but requires careful cooking to prevent dryness.
- Pork belly – While not traditional, pork belly can add a layer of fattiness, making the dish richer.
Like beef birria, some people mix different cuts of pork to balance tenderness and flavor. For example, pork shoulder and ribs can create a deeper, more complex taste.
Should You Mix Different Meats?
Some cooks like to mix beef and pork to create a unique birria variation. This approach allows for the best of both worlds—the deep, bold flavor of beef combined with the natural sweetness and tenderness of pork. If using both meats, it is important to adjust the cooking time, as pork generally cooks faster than beef.
6: How to Serve Birria (Tacos, Consomé, and More)
Birria Tacos: Why Beef is Preferred
One of the most popular ways to enjoy birria is in tacos, especially the crispy, cheesy birria tacos that have taken over social media and food trucks. Beef is the preferred meat for birria tacos because of its rich, fatty texture that crisps up beautifully on a griddle. When shredded beef birria is placed inside a corn tortilla, dipped in consomé, and fried until golden brown, it creates the perfect combination of crispy, juicy, and flavorful.
Pork birria can also be used for tacos, but because pork is naturally softer and less fatty, it doesn’t crisp up as well as beef. While pork birria tacos are still delicious, they tend to have a different texture and flavor compared to the bold, meaty bite of beef birria tacos.
Pork Birria in Tamales and Soups
Although beef dominates birria tacos, pork birria is often used in other dishes such as tamales and stews. The natural tenderness of pork makes it a great filling for tamales, as it blends well with the masa and chili-based sauce.
Pork birria is also commonly enjoyed in a rich, spicy broth, similar to traditional birria de chivo (goat birria). The slightly sweet and juicy flavor of pork pairs well with the deep, smoky notes of dried chilies, making it a comforting and flavorful dish when served as a stew.
The Best Sides and Toppings for Birria
Whether using beef or pork, birria is best served with the right toppings and sides to enhance its flavors.
- Onions and cilantro – Freshly chopped onions and cilantro add brightness and a bit of crunch.
- Lime wedges – A squeeze of lime balances the richness of the meat and consomé.
- Radishes – Thinly sliced radishes provide a refreshing contrast to the deep flavors of the birria.
- Avocado or guacamole – Creamy avocado complements the spice and smokiness of birria.
- Mexican rice and beans – A classic side dish that pairs well with the slow-cooked meat.
- Corn tortillas – Essential for making tacos or dipping into the consomé.
No matter how birria is served, the combination of slow-cooked meat, flavorful broth, and traditional Mexican toppings creates a dish that is deeply satisfying and full of rich, bold flavors.
7: Birria’s Popularity in the U.S.
How Birria Became a Food Trend
In recent years, birria has exploded in popularity across the United States, becoming one of the most sought-after Mexican dishes. What was once a traditional dish from Jalisco has now turned into a global food trend, thanks to food trucks, social media, and viral videos showcasing cheesy, crispy birria tacos dipped into rich, flavorful consomé.
The rise of birria in the U.S. can be traced back to Los Angeles, where Mexican food vendors began offering birria tacos in the early 2010s. As customers lined up for the juicy, crispy tacos filled with tender shredded beef, the dish quickly gained momentum. Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube further fueled the craze, with millions of people watching videos of tacos being dipped into steaming hot consomé.
Why Most Restaurants Use Beef Birria
While birria was originally made with goat, and some regions in Mexico still prepare pork birria, beef birria has become the standard in the U.S. There are a few key reasons why most restaurants and food trucks choose beef over other meats.
- Beef is more widely available than goat, making it easier for restaurants to source high-quality cuts.
- The fat content in beef makes it ideal for slow cooking, resulting in a richer, more flavorful dish.
- Beef holds up well in tacos, allowing for a perfect crispy texture when fried on a griddle.
- Customers in the U.S. are more familiar with beef, making it a more approachable option compared to goat or pork.
Because of these factors, birria de res has become the dominant version served in restaurants across the country. While pork birria is still enjoyed in some places, it has not gained the same level of recognition as beef birria.
Can You Find Pork Birria in the U.S.?
Although beef birria is the most common, some restaurants and home cooks still make birria using pork. In certain regions with a strong Mexican community, you may find birria de cerdo on the menu, especially in traditional family-owned restaurants. However, it is much less common than beef birria and is typically found in areas with strong ties to central and southern Mexican cuisine.
Some people also choose to make pork birria at home as a variation of the dish. Since pork cooks faster than beef and has a naturally tender texture, it can be an appealing choice for those who want a different take on traditional birria.
8: FAQs
Is birria usually pork or beef?
Birria is most commonly made with beef today, especially in the United States and northern Mexico. However, traditionally, birria was made with goat meat in Jalisco, Mexico. Some regions, particularly in central and southern Mexico, also make birria with pork. While pork birria exists as a variation, beef has become the dominant choice due to its availability, rich flavor, and ideal texture for tacos.
Can birria be made with pork?
Yes, birria can be made with pork, and it is known as birria de cerdo. Pork birria is less common than beef birria but is still enjoyed in certain regions of Mexico. It is typically made with pork shoulder or pork ribs, which become tender and flavorful when slow-cooked in a chili-based marinade. Pork birria has a slightly sweeter and milder taste compared to beef birria, making it a great alternative for those who prefer a softer texture.
Are birria tacos always beef?
Birria tacos are most commonly made with beef, especially in the U.S., where birria de res is the standard. The fat content in beef makes it ideal for frying, creating the crispy, juicy texture that has made birria tacos so popular. However, some people do make birria tacos with pork, goat, or even lamb. While pork birria tacos exist, they are not as widely available as the beef version, which remains the preferred choice for most restaurants and food vendors.
What animal part is birria?
Birria can be made using different cuts of meat depending on the type of meat used. For beef birria, popular cuts include chuck roast, short ribs, brisket, and beef shank, all of which become tender when slow-cooked. For pork birria, the most commonly used parts are pork shoulder, pork butt, and pork ribs. Traditional goat birria often uses leg or shoulder cuts. Regardless of the type of meat, the key to a good birria is choosing cuts with enough fat and connective tissue to break down during the slow-cooking process, resulting in a rich and flavorful dish.
9: Conclusion
Which is Better: Beef or Pork Birria?
The choice between beef and pork birria ultimately comes down to personal preference and how you plan to enjoy the dish. Beef birria has a bold, rich flavor with a slightly smoky taste, making it the best option for tacos. Its higher fat content allows the meat to crisp up beautifully when fried, creating the signature texture that has made birria tacos so popular.
Pork birria, on the other hand, is softer and slightly sweeter. While it may not crisp up as well as beef, it is an excellent choice for stews, tamales, and other traditional Mexican dishes. The tenderness of pork makes it easier to cook in a shorter amount of time, which is ideal for those who want a flavorful birria without waiting for hours.
Final Thoughts on Choosing the Right Meat
Both beef and pork birria have their own unique qualities, and neither is wrong. If you are looking for a traditional taste, you might want to try goat birria, which is the original version from Jalisco. However, if you prefer a more accessible and familiar option, beef is the most popular choice, especially for tacos. For those who enjoy a slightly different take on the dish, pork birria offers a tender and juicy alternative.
No matter which meat you choose, the key to a great birria lies in slow-cooking the meat in a flavorful chili marinade and serving it with fresh toppings and warm tortillas. Whether you enjoy it as a stew, in tacos, or with consomé for dipping, birria remains one of Mexico’s most delicious and versatile dishes.
Now that you know the differences between beef and pork birria, you can try making both versions and decide which one is your favorite.
For more recipes and cooking tips, visit Adora Recipes.